The horror. The horror.
Everytime I read about the alleged Nov. 19 massacre by U.S. Marines of 24 Iraqi civilians in the town of Haditha, which becomes more confirmed every day, I think of the hacked up and dying Col. Kurtz in the film "Apocalypse Now" gasping out, "The horror. The horror." It was meant as a metaphor for the Vietnam War, but it looks like it may now apply to Iraq as well.
Despite what happened in Vietnam in well-known massacres such as My Lai, where about 500 civilians died, Americans retain the ability to be shocked that our boys could willfully murder innocent civilians, especially children, to avenge a slain comrade. We retain mental images of our heroic liberation of Europe in World War II, and of G.I.'s tossing Hershey bars to the kids. U.S. Marines simply couldn't do that, we insist. But they can, and they did. The question is why. It isn't a defense to say, quite correctly, that the other side is worse. We are supposed to be better. It is the mark of a civilized nation.
Soldiers of many lands have committed atrocities: Germans, French, English, Americans, Russians, Japanese and no doubt others. Americans are not exceptional. They are human. In the stress of battle, if military discipline breaks down, as it apparently did in Haditha, bad things can happen. It is the price we inevitably pay for fighting wars that have no purpose beyond the ideological or idiotic. Saddam Hussein was bad, sure. So was the Argentine junta in the 1970s, which threw leftist dissidents out of airplanes. Nothing was done. So was General Pinochet of Chile, but America didn't invade Chile. We sent conservative economists to remake their economy into a Republican fantasyland, complete with privatized Social Security.
I wonder where the sergeants and officers of the Marines were while this massacre was going on. How far up the chain of command did knowledge of the Haditha massacre reach before it was first reported by Time magazine? The My Lai massacre remained secret for much longer, about a year, until reporter Seymour Hersh broke the story. The Army went after officers in that one, including Col. Oran K. Henderson, who later moved to Carlisle, Pa., and became the first director of the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency. Henderson was accused of covering up the massacre but was aquitted at court martial, although the findings of the case were devastating. No one, in fact, was truly punished for My Lai. Perhaps if they had been, the atrocities of the Iraq war, from the Abu Ghraib prison abuses to Haditha, would have been less likely to happen. But I doubt it. War is hell.
The saddest outcome of this, other than the deaths themselves, will be the tarnishing of the reputation of all American soldiers. Most Marines do their job and do it well without a hint of scandal. We need to bring all American troops home now. That is the only thing that will prevent Haditha from happening again.


